PMs and Subs Play ‘Win as Much as You Can’
July 30th, 2006 by HalSubcontractors have a different focus from contractors derived in part from working on multiple projects simultaneously rather than one at a time. The researchers used a computer simulation to examine resource allocation behaviors.
Subcontractor Resource Allocation in a MultiProject Environment
Michael Harel and Rafael Sacks
They performed a survey of 28 contractors and 29 subcontractors for the basis of establishing a better utility function than the inferred "win as much as you can" approach.
In only 55% of the cases did PMs enable subcontractors to work with effective crew sizes
Some of the findings:
- More than 48% of project managers admitted to exagerating resource requirements by at least 20%
- More than 75% of project managers assume a priori that Subs will bring less than 80% of the resources needed
- The average amount of work ready expected was only 60%
- 40% of PMs admit that contract price was the prime reason for selectin a subcontractor
- The researchers concluded that in only 55% of the cases did PMs enable subcontractors to work with effective crew sizes.
- Subcontractors adopt a defensive behavior of overbooking their resources while supplying fewer resources than demanded.
The survey results confirmed the original mistrust-exploit view of contractor-subcontractor behavior. PMs and Subs are more likely to play 'Win as Much as You Can' than not.
Related Posts
- Games Project Teams Play A project team has a chance to succeed when team members feel free to fully express how they are doing, what help they n...
- Indifference, Inertia, and Insight I love reading the columnists at Industry Week. I subscribe to the IW newsletters so not to miss them. This one just i...
- Audience Reactions to SSM’s “This Changes Everything” Key Points Problems are universal Alignment from IFoA and shared incentives Asking the question, "WHat makes ...
- Explore a PM’s Brain Raven shares her curiosity and interests at Raven's Brain as she explores the world of project management. Explore with...
- Catch Hal in Orange County I'm speaking at the PMI Orange County Chapter on Aug 13th. It's a Saturday. That's a big deal for me since I live no...
July 31st, 2006 at 9:17 am
Hal–what’s the punchline on that second bullet point? “75% of project managers” …. what? Inquiring minds want to know!
July 31st, 2006 at 10:00 am
My late night editing wasn’t so good! I updated the bullet point with the punchline. The survey in a way just confirmed our suspicions — subcontractors don’t think they will be taken care of by the PMs and PMs think they will be lied to by the subs. Acting to protect their own interests (not those of the client) the parties relationships devolve along with the reliability of the project.
February 21st, 2007 at 9:37 pm
I agree. That’s the problem with hiring subcontractors, they (and the project team) usually have their own interests. A good supplier contract will usually make sure that both parties meet the same end goal.